The best line in the novel:
Julian had once told me that a story is a letter the author writes to himself, to tell himself things that he would be unable to discover otherwise. (p. 363)
While the novel was fast paced, interesting, complex, and loaded with characters, intrigue and conflicts to propel the mystery along, I would not be prone to call this novel either a masterpiece or a destined-to-be classic, thus disagreeing with The Daily Telegraph’s front and back cover blurbs.
The main character, Daniel, is a bit of a crybaby and a manipulator, a mirror of the subject of his search, the mysterious author, Julian Carax. Other characters do stand out, in particular, his friend Fermin. But without sympathy for the two main characters, it’s hard to accept a lot of their actions.
One of my biggest problems with this novel is the question of whether this novel is carefully plotted or merely overly contrived. There are just too many coincidences between Daniel and Julian, in personality and events. Carlos Ruiz Zafon winds two pretty complicated stories here, but he ties them together by making them almost unbelievably similar separated only by time. Daniel not only looks like Julian, impregnates his first lover, a seventeen year-old girl just as did Julian, and more, but they even are presented with the same "Victor Hugo wrote with it" fountain pen as some point early in their writing careers.
There was another problem of Zafon foreshadowing beautifully, then overdoing the hints and finally presenting the obvious like it was a big surprise or something. With several references to the fact that the hatter who raises Julian may not be his real father, and the many related adventures of Penelope’s father as well as the dissatisfaction of Sophie, Julian’s mother, Zafon actually "drops the bomb" at the end of a chapter: Julian and Penelope may be lovers, but they’re also brother and sister! The impact just wasn’t there for me since I’d guessed it a hundred pages prior. There was also another "bomb" that got diffused. At the end of the first person pov narrative by Daniel, he claims that within a week he’d be dead. After an inset and change of pov to a a first person of another character where a lot of backstory is given, we are returned to Daniel’s story and find that he had officially stopped breathing for sixty seconds. My guess was more dramatic: he officially lost his personality as Daniel and became Julian. This is another area where Zafon should leave some questions up to the readers.
Then there’s the fact that Zafon handles this information rather strangely. While it tells us why Penelope’s father was so infuriated when he finds out who got her pregnant, it would also make sense for Julian’s friends to give him this information at some point in the twenty years after she dies in childbirth rather than have him blame himself for her death when they finally tell him she’s dead.
There are some character descriptions that are not changes as a result of the situations, but rather what I almost see as a slip-up by Zafon. Nuria describes Julian’s later behavior as nasty, yet caring about Daniel. The evil Fumero was madly in love with Penelope and his hate for Julian and his friends drives his actions, yet he refers once to Penelope as a "tart."
Some questions about technical information also arise. Daniel goes to the mansion and sees the coffins, and yet Nuria’s message to Daniel claims that Julian has moved the coffins. There were many of these that had me flipping through pages backward to check out details.
So while I enjoyed the novel enough to overlook the millions of street names and most of the huh? moments, I’m still left with some burning question: How did Daniel find that one hidden book in the library? Why did he love the book when none of Julian’s novels sold well? And the hottest of all: Why did Julian burn his books?